Here's the 5pm, 5-day forecast which shows the storm center at 18.5N 58.5W on Sunday, Sept 17th at 2pm. St. Maarten is at 18.0° N 63.1° W
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4e99f/4e99fcfaa604ad5b6313f56f7c9171e4f9784a00" alt=""
A little bit of a song is going through my head... "should I stay or should I go"...
We'll be keeping an eye out!